Hoggy's BBQ in Columbus, Ohio: Our Date Night Review and What to Order
Hoggy's covered our meal; we weren't paid. Opinions are our own.
Hoggy's BBQ and Catering is the family-run barbecue spot on Bethel Road in Columbus, Ohio, and on our date night there in early May 2026 we called it the best BBQ we have ever eaten. We tried two signature sandwiches, a meat sampler with ribs, pulled pork and brisket, three sides and three house sauces, and we sat down with owner Kyle Turner. Here is what we ordered, his story, the official menu and hours, and an honest answer to "is Hoggy's the best BBQ in Columbus?" from people who have only been once.
More Central Ohio date nights and eats: Columbus Rooftop Bar Crawl · All Central Ohio eats
- Quick facts
- Our date night at Hoggy's BBQ in Columbus
- What we ordered at Hoggy's
- Meet the owner: Kyle Turner
- Is Hoggy's the best BBQ in Columbus?
- Hoggy's vs City Barbeque in Columbus
- Hoggy's BBQ menu and prices
- FAQ
Quick facts
| Address | 830 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43214 On Bethel Road on Columbus's Northwest Side. |
|---|---|
| Phone | (614) 442-1800 |
| Best for | BBQ date night, families, couples, group platters, takeout and catering |
| Style | Scratch-made Southern BBQ: hand-rubbed meats, slow-smoked 12 to 16 hours (per Hoggy's) |
| Must-try | Mogee's Mac, the brisket and the pulled pork |
| Ordering | Online ordering at hoggys.com/order |
| Catering | Yes, Hoggy's also runs a catering business |
| Locations | One Hoggy's restaurant, on Bethel Road |
| Our visit | Early May 2026, our first visit. They covered our meal; we weren't paid |
Hours (checked Nov 20, 2026)
| Monday to Sunday | 11 am to 8 pm |
|---|
Official site · Menu / schedule · Order online · Map
Our date night at Hoggy's BBQ in Columbus
We went to Hoggy's for a date night in early May 2026, about a week before we posted the TikTok on May 16, and it was our first visit. We captioned the video that it was hands down the best BBQ spot we've ever eaten at. You could literally smell the barbecue as soon as you got out of the car, and we were excited to try it because the menu has some unusual things on it, like cheese on brisket.
We haven't been back yet. We're busy, and it's a drive from our house. But if we wanted good BBQ, we'd go there. It was incredible. We took a bunch of food home and can't wait for the next time.
What we ordered at Hoggy's (and what to order)
We ordered two signature sandwiches, a sampler platter so we could try the different meats, three sides and three of the house-made sauces. The sandwiches, the Pimento Philly and the Smoke and Sharp, were specials Hoggy's was running when we went. They may not be on the menu now: the current online menu doesn't list them, so ask when you order.
- Pimento Philly: one of the two special sandwiches. Each of us had a favorite between the two, and this one was really good.
- Smoke and Sharp: the cheese-on-brisket special. The cheese and the brisket are a match made in heaven, and this sandwich got the "by far my favorite" vote.
- Brisket: tender and juicy, and some of the best brisket we've ever had.
- Pulled pork: tender and good, and again some of the best we've ever had.
- Ribs: fall-off-the-bone good.
- Mogee's Mac: Hoggy's mac and cheese. We thought it was incredible; Hoggy's says it is a three-generation family recipe.
- Smoked Garlic and Cheese Mash: red skin mashed potatoes with smoked garlic, layered with gouda and cheddar, per the menu. Really tasty.
- Garlic and Bacon Green Beans: our one vegetable, and delicious.
- Sauces: all of the house sauces were amazing. The Columbus Dispatch reported in 2021 that Hoggy's blends most of its sauces in-house.
Meet the owner: Kyle Turner
We sat down with owner Kyle Turner for about half an hour, just getting to know him and the story of Hoggy's. He was super cool. It's very clear he knows what he's doing, and he genuinely cares about his restaurant and wants people to have an all-around good experience.
The story behind it is a good one. Hoggy's started in 1991 in Linworth, grew into a local chain, and then shrank after the last of its sit-down restaurants closed around 2013, and the brand kept going on Bethel Road. Kyle is the son of co-founder Mark Turner, and his family history is told in 614NOW's Hoggy's profile: he joined the business in 2017, pushed to drop the Johnny Buccelli's sandwich concept that shared the building, and focused the menu on BBQ. In the Columbus Dispatch's 30-years story, Kyle described the rebrand and the reworked dining room, and the paper reported that Hoggy's blends most of its sauces and makes its pickles, pickled onions and pimento cheese in-house (as of January 2021).
If you'd like to hear it from Kyle himself, he has talked about the comeback and Hoggy's approach on the 614 Feast podcast, in his 2021 episode and a 2023 episode on Columbus-style barbecue.
Is Hoggy's the best BBQ in Columbus?
For us, on our one visit, yes: it was the best barbecue we've ever eaten. But we haven't eaten at the other Columbus barbecue spots on the lists, so we can't honestly rank Hoggy's against all of them. Here is what independent sources say.
In Columbus Monthly's 2024 readers' poll, Hoggy's placed third for Best Barbecue, behind Ray Ray's Hog Pit and City Barbeque (Best of Columbus 2024). In the 2025 poll the top three were Ray Ray's Hog Pit, City Barbeque and Legacy Smokehouse (Best of Columbus 2025).
In August 2024, Texas Monthly's barbecue editor, Daniel Vaughn, named Hoggy's among the honorable mentions in his tour of the best Texas-style barbecue outside Texas and recommended the smoked and fried wings with Jamaican Me Crazy sauce (Texas Monthly; 614NOW's summary). We didn't order the wings, so we can't speak to them.
Hoggy's vs City Barbeque in Columbus
City Barbeque paid us for a sponsored video and covered our meal. You can watch it on TikTok. Hoggy's covered our meal but did not pay us.
City Barbeque is a Columbus-born fast-casual chain that started in a renovated donut shop in Upper Arlington in 1999 and now has dozens of locations in several states (per its own site). We liked how easy it made a family night, with customizable family packs for gatherings of any size, and readers clearly like it too: it placed second for Best Barbecue in Columbus Monthly's 2024 and 2025 polls.
Our honest take: Hoggy's wins by a wide margin for us. City Barbeque was the paid partner and we still preferred Hoggy's, which is a good reason to trust our opinion here. City Barbeque's food didn't stand out for us the way Hoggy's did. This is our own taste from one meal at each, not a verdict on anyone's hard work. Kyle has said that several barbecue places in town can all be good (on 614 Feast), and 614NOW reports he looked to local powerhouses like Ray Ray's and City Barbeque for inspiration while rebuilding Hoggy's (614NOW). If you want a convenient family dinner, City Barbeque's setup may suit you. If you want our pick for good BBQ, it's Hoggy's.
Hoggy's BBQ menu and prices
Prices from Hoggy's own online menu, checked Nov 20, 2026. They change, so confirm when you order. The online menu we checked lists meats by weight, group packs, sides, wings, ribs and desserts. The Pimento Philly and Smoke and Sharp were specials when we went and aren't listed there.
- Meats, by weight (quarter pound or half pound): pork $9.00 or $15.00, brisket $11.50 or $19.50, herb-marinated smoked chicken thigh $9.00 or $15.00, smoked turkey breast $10.00 or $18.00.
- Samplers: 2 Meat Sampler $26.00 regular or $40.00 large; Grazer (three meats, three sides, three sauces) $42.00 regular or $60.00 large; Family Pack (four meats, four sides) $56.00 regular or $80.00 large.
- Ribs: half rack $18.00, full rack $34.00. Smofried chicken wings start at $7.50.
- Sides: Mogee's Mac $3.99 small or $5.99 large, plus Smoked Garlic and Cheese Mash, Classic Coleslaw, Garlic and Bacon Green Beans, Dill and Citrus Potato Salad, Grandma's Baked Beans, Picnic Broccoli Salad and Beef Tallow Fries.
- Desserts, $6.00 each: Hoggy's Pudding (banana pudding with caramel and vanilla wafers), Wagyu Chocolate Chip Cookie, Southern Style Peach Cobbler and a Chocolate Brownie.
Mogee's Mac: Hoggy's mac and cheese
Hoggy's describes Mogee's Mac as its grandmother's baked mac and cheese, a three-generation family recipe made with three cheeses, sour cream, cottage cheese and two types of noodles, and says it has earned "Best Mac & Cheese" in Columbus. That is Hoggy's own claim, and we haven't seen a poll that backs it up. We did find the mac incredible. We didn't find a published recipe on Hoggy's site, so we won't guess at one.
Hoggy's smoked and fried wings, ribs and catering
Hoggy's describes its wings as marinated in buttermilk and dill pickle for 24 hours, smoked over applewood and finished in beef tallow. It describes its ribs as spare ribs, applewood-smoked competition-style. We ate the ribs as part of our sampler; we didn't order the wings. Hoggy's also caters, and its site lists birthdays, graduations, weddings and holiday events.
What it's like inside Hoggy's
Great vibes. We think Hoggy's works well for families and for couples. The restaurant had been recently renovated when we went, and the vibe is solid.
Hoggy's BBQ hours, ordering and location
Hoggy's lists 11 am to 8 pm every day on its online ordering page, checked Nov 20, 2026. You can order online at hoggys.com or call (614) 442-1800. The restaurant is at 830 Bethel Road in Columbus, Ohio 43214. It is the only Hoggy's restaurant: the Columbus Dispatch reported in 2021 that the lone Hoggy's is on Bethel Road (Dispatch), and Hoggy's own site lists only that address, so there is no Polaris or Dublin location.
Other Columbus BBQ spots we haven't tried yet
Looking for more Columbus barbecue? These are other places that come up in best-BBQ lists. We have not eaten at any of them, we are not ranking them, and the details below come from each place's own site, checked Nov 20, 2026. Hours change, so check before you go.
Ray Ray's Hog Pit
Ray Ray's Hog Pit has four central Ohio locations: Clintonville, Franklinton (at Land-Grant Brewing), Westerville and Granville. Its site lists Thursday to Sunday hours at several of them, so see rayrayshogpit.com/locations for the one nearest you. It topped Columbus Monthly's 2024 and 2025 readers' polls for barbecue.
Smoked on High BBQ (Brewery District)
Smoked on High is at 755 S High St and lists Wednesday to Sunday, 11 am to 8 pm or until it sells out. Its site says the restaurant is takeout and pickup only, with a patio and porch to eat outdoors (smokedonhigh.com).
Hank's Texas BBQ (Clintonville)
Hank's is at 2941 N High St. Its site lists Tuesday to Thursday and Sunday, 11:30 am to 9 pm, Friday and Saturday, 11:30 am to 10 pm, and closed Mondays (hankstexasstylebbq.com). There is a second Hank's in Delaware.
B&K Smoke House (Olde Towne East)
B&K is at 1114 E Main St. Its contact page lists Wednesday to Friday, 11 am to 8 pm, Saturday 12 to 8 pm, Sunday 12 to 6 pm, and Monday and Tuesday as temporarily closed (bksmokehousebbq.com).
Our verdict
Hoggy's is where we'd send a friend who asks for good BBQ in Columbus: scratch-made, slow-smoked, a menu with a few surprises, a mac and cheese that's worth the trip on its own, and an owner who clearly cares. We loved it enough to call it the best we've ever had. We can't tell you it beats every other spot in town, but we can tell you what we ate, what we'd order again, and that Hoggy's covered our meal but didn't pay us and didn't see this page first.
Hoggy's BBQ and Catering FAQs
Where is Hoggy's BBQ in Columbus?
Hoggy's BBQ and Catering is at 830 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43214, on the Northwest Side. It is the only Hoggy's restaurant, and the phone number is (614) 442-1800.
What are Hoggy's BBQ hours?
Hoggy's lists 11 am to 8 pm every day on its online ordering page, checked Nov 20, 2026.
Is Hoggy's the best BBQ in Columbus?
We called it the best BBQ spot we've ever eaten at, but we've only been once and haven't tried every spot, so we can't rank it against all of them. Readers placed it third for Best Barbecue in Columbus Monthly's 2024 poll, behind Ray Ray's Hog Pit and City Barbeque.
Hoggy's vs City Barbeque: which is better?
City Barbeque paid us for a sponsored video and covered our meal, and we still preferred Hoggy's by a wide margin. That is our own opinion from one meal at each. Hoggy's covered our meal but did not pay us. City Barbeque placed second for Best Barbecue in Columbus Monthly's 2024 and 2025 polls.
What should you order at Hoggy's?
On our visit we loved the brisket, the pulled pork, the ribs, two special sandwiches and the sides, especially Mogee's Mac. The Grazer sampler is a good way to try several meats and sauces.
Who owns Hoggy's BBQ?
Kyle Turner, the son of co-founder Mark Turner, runs Hoggy's. The family opened the first Hoggy's in Linworth in 1991, and the only restaurant today is on Bethel Road.
Does Hoggy's have other locations, like Polaris or Linworth?
No. Hoggy's started in Linworth in 1991 and once had many locations, but the only Hoggy's restaurant today is on Bethel Road in Columbus, per its own site and the Columbus Dispatch.
What is in Hoggy's mac and cheese?
Hoggy's says Mogee's Mac is a three-generation family recipe made with three cheeses, sour cream, cottage cheese and two types of noodles. We didn't find a published recipe.
Does Hoggy's cater?
Yes. Hoggy's BBQ and Catering offers catering for events such as birthdays, graduations, weddings and holiday parties.
Did Hoggy's pay you for this review?
No. Hoggy's covered our meal, but we weren't paid, and our opinions are our own.